Pope-King Joe
I hate pants. Founder of The Ungodly Geeks Podcast, coming back eventually! Maybe!
I used to play a lot of Destiny 2. Reddit refugee. I run Arch btw.
IF THE ZOO BANS ME FOR HOLLERING AT THE ANIMALS I WILL FACE GOD AND WALK BACKWARDS INTO HELL
Primary Alt Account: popekingjoe[at]lemmynsfw.com
- 0 Posts
- 192 Comments
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Reddit's traffic is down 13%, partly thanks to AI OverviewsEnglish
6·6 days agoThat’s the spirit!
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Linux@lemmy.ml•Microsoft WSL product manager Craig Loewen announces CachyOS now supports running under WSL (with plans to add it to the official list).English
2·15 days agoI have great experience with it when it comes to standby time. I sometimes will bring it with me to work to play around on my lunch hour, and if I don’t end up pulling it out of my backpack, it’ll drop maybe 4-5% over a ~10 hour period. Of course, actual use can be a mixed bag, but I tended to get a few hours of modded Minecraft before needing to reach for a charger.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•FAA to finally ditch floppy disks in what it calls "historic" tech upgradeEnglish
23·15 days agoThey have now upgraded to zip drives.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Linux@lemmy.ml•Microsoft WSL product manager Craig Loewen announces CachyOS now supports running under WSL (with plans to add it to the official list).English
7·15 days agoIt’s pretty damn solid. I’ve been running it on my Framework 13 AMD 7040 for years, and I recently acquired a 64GB Framework Desktop and it’s running like a dream on it. Definitely recommend it for (mostly) effortless Arch.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Motorola Signature 27 with GrapheneOS will cost €1.900English
1·16 days agoI mean… I did buy the carrying handle… 🤔
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Motorola Signature 27 with GrapheneOS will cost €1.900English
13·17 days agoOof.
That’s about how much my Framework Desktop cost. I think I’ll stick with my Pixel Fold.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Proton Employees are starting a unionization driveEnglish
19·18 days agoFuck yeah good luck to them.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Battle over Meta’s alleged Bolsonaro bias intensifies days before Brazil presidential runoffEnglish
5·1 month agoBest of luck to you friend. 🫡
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Companies Are Realizing They’re Spending a Fortune on AI Just So Their Employees Can Generate Error-Riddled Slop, and Suddenly Cutting Back Budgets.English
111·1 month agoOh look, the thing we all knew was gonna happen is happening.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•MapQuest will now show you where Flock cameras are in your neighborhoodEnglish
13·1 month agoFuck yeah dude shoutout to mapquest.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•Scientists just voted to redefine how the world keeps timeEnglish
14·1 month agoAt least we’ll get an extra hour here in several thousand years.
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•DHS Inspector General Finds That TSA is Not Properly Safeguarding Passenger Facial Recognition DataEnglish
5·1 month agoOf course. This makes perfect sense.
‘AI’ is Not a Tool Rich Hickey
(I keep delivering this as a quip, here’s a bit more)
First order of business - is ‘tool’ going to have an interesting, distinguishing and thus illuminative meaning or be a mere platitudinous stand-in for “anything useful”?
We’ll save tool as “anyone/thing that can be exploited” for the AI titans, for whom VCs, politicians, wannabe-titan-CEOs, software devs, rural towns etc are all ‘tools’. The pockets on the front of my shirts are useful (I need to keep my reading glasses handy), but they are not tools. Similarly, fast food drive-thru windows are useful, but are not tools (more later).
Some definitions of ‘tool’:
a device or implement, especially one held in the hand, used to carry out a particular function an instrument (such as a hammer or saw) used or worked by hand : an instrument used by a handicraftsperson or laborer in their workWhat I like best - A tool is something you wield.
wield - to use (as a tool or instrument) especially with full command or power : handle, manipulate, controlEspecially useful in that are:
Held in your hand - a source of both control and feedback, and an indication of the intimacy of the act of use Power - force, energy transmission and direction, leverage etc Control - intention and continuous directing of the course of eventsTools are implements with which you do something, they do not do things for you. Tool use builds, rewards, and often requires, expertise and skill. The continuous application of technique and energy, and sensory feedback, are essential to the buildup of expertise (from experiri - “try”).
Good tools have many properties LLMs lack - they are predictable, reliable, deterministic, of bounded function, hopefully simple etc.
What you learn while wielding a tool is something about the world, the task, the physics, logic etc of what you are trying to do or the situation you are trying to overcome. And often, something about yourself. Recommended by LinkedIn
As a lifelong tool builder and user, I know what tools are. LLMs are not tools.
Control, sensory feedback, intention, intimacy, continuous direction, expertise etc are all missing from LLM use. LLMs are not wielded. LLMs are automation.
automation - (of a device or process) working by itself with little or no direct human control.A drive-thru is not a tool for cooking, it is automation for avoiding cooking. LLMs are not tools with which you write code - they are automation with which you avoid writing code, to which you abdicate writing code.
You don’t direct the action of an LLM - you make requests and it acts on its own, without your energy or continuous direction. This request/automation cycle is not wielding, it’s not control, it’s not continuous, it’s without feedback.
What you are doing while using automation, instead of learning real-world truths, is attempting to divine the details du jour of some automaton. And striving to game them - e.g. ordering a custom burger (no onions) in order to get a freshly made one. Or filling voodoo.md with just the right incantations. You are only a software update from everything you’ve ‘learned’ being rendered obsolete by the latest algorithm. (A soggy cold burger from which the onions have been removed) You have traded working with the world to working for a capricious robot.
It is a mistake to be haphazard about “tools” being equivalent to utility, e.g. saying - “the LLM didn’t write my paper, I just used it as a tool to read and summarize some research papers”. But you didn’t wield it to read those papers (as you might a Kindle). It read the papers, not you.
What do you miss by abdicating doing the reading? Pretty much everything. First and foremost, you miss learning how to write from those who can. You miss learning how to formulate an argument. You miss noticing things. You miss loading your background mind with fodder for novel ideas. You miss building trust in some authors and suspicion of others. You miss all the jokes. You miss all of the edges. You miss learning how to think.
Tools don’t get “misaligned”, they don’t “go rogue”, they don’t “escape containment”, “conspire” etc.
LLMs are not tools. I know many people use the phrase “just tools” simply to indicate “they are what you make of them”. Except that’s not true. Automation has intrinsic properties and differences from tools that you ignore at your peril.
Rich
Pope-King Joe@lemmy.worldto
Selfhosted@lemmy.world•How do you monitor your servers?English
5·1 month agoI usually just walk down the hall and move the mouse. I don’t really need remote monitoring. 😅





I once nuked my root drive because I typo’d the command. It happens OP.